|
Allahabad – 20th January
2001
Tourism,
Religion, Politics and the Media at the Kumbh Mela.
By Tony Fernandes
The Luxury Tourist Resort
The International tour operator Cox &
Kings (C&K) has found itself in the middle of major controversy here
at the Kumbh Mela. Influential maha-mandeleshwars who run well known
akaharas here decided some time ago that C & K had broken many of
the rules which groups pitching tents within the mela area are supposed
to abide by.
C & K managed to get 12 bigha of land
(about 7 acres) allotted to them for the ridiculously low sum of 300,000
rupees without going through the usual tender or auction procedure. C
& K’s aim was to set up a premium tourist camp consisting of
luxury tents within the Mela area catering primarily to the rich and
famous. If press reports are to be believed we can expect among other
famous personalities; Madonna, Richard Gere, Demi Moore, Sharon Stone,
Pierce Brosnan and Robert De Niro to be turning up here sometime soon.
They will require high quality facilities that only C & K can give
them.
Nobody is quite certain how this issue
came to be taken up, perhaps it could be the discovery that C & K
were allegedly charging over $240 per night. A commercial enterprise
making a lot of money catering for up to 600 premium tourists was bound
to get some people pissed off. A number of Akaharas began to accuse the
mela administration of failing to maintain the integrity of the mela
grounds by allowing a commercial enterprise to operate here. They also
accused C & K of supplying meat and alcohol to its guests, both of
which are strictly forbidden in the mela area. The mela administration
was told that if it did not shut down the activities of C & K, the
akaharas would do it for them. To keep the Akaharas at bay, the chief
mela officer issued C & K with a notice canceling their license,
knowing that C & K would apply to the Allahabad High Court to
prevent any action being taken immediately. In India as elsewhere, this
is an expensive way of buying time. All this was happening before the
first big bathing day Makar Sankranti on 14th January. By 16th
January the matter was in India’s Supreme Court. Imagine the clout
required to get the hearing pushed right up to the top so quickly. The
Supreme Court requested that the petitioners appear before the Allahabad
Divisional Commissioner on 18th January.
Nobody really wants C & K out because
there is too much at stake. The celebrities who are expected to stay at
the C & K resort will give the MahaKumbh the kind of international
exposure Indians crave. Channel 4 in Britain has a dedicated website on
the Kumbh and 10-minute nightly TV coverage of the daily events here.
They have 52 members of their team staying at the C & K camp. Other
influential people are also staying there. Channel 4 is profiling a
number of people including the chief administrative officer of the mela,
Mr. Jeevesh Nandan who is one of the most powerful officials here. The
mela administration has made a number of compromises to keep the Akahara
Parishad happy. There is no scope in this article to go into all of the
details because there are many forces at play here. Since the holiday
resort story is the one on which the game is played, it is the one that
gets written about and swallowed and so let us leave it at that.
Whatever happens, ways are going to be found to drag this thing past the
most important dates and then when C & K are good and ready to
leave, they will.
The Media
Being a member of the public, covering
the Kumbh Mela has felt good. At various points in the past few days I
have deliberately stayed among the pilgrims and away from the journalist
side of the fence where better views were to be had. Two days ago, while
on my way back to base, I decided to walk into the Media camp and check
out what was required to get accreditation as a bona fide mela
journalist. Here is a list of some of the more interesting questions I
would be required to answer to get a Kumbh Mela accredited journalist
pass: husband’s or father’s name; professional experience in
chronological order with salary details and total monthly emoluments;
revenue of publication per annum; addresses of places of stay in the
past five years. Well! I did not stay there long.
In the past few days there has been a lot
of heat generated over the issue of photographing naked Naga Sadhus and
women bathing at the ghats. Unflattering pictures which appeared in the
papers have angered many. The Indian community watching Channel 4's mela
coverage protested to the channel and to the Indian High Commission in
London. All photographers will now be restricted from taking photos or
video footage of women having their bath at the ghats and of Naga Sadhus.
A number of TV networks including the BBC, ABC, CNN, Channel 4 and
stations from France, Japan, Israel and Hungary were planning to present
live coverage of bathing at the Sangam during Mauni Amavasya on 24th
January. A compromise is being worked out. Distant shots of bathing will
be permitted, but no close-ups. Networks who are not happy with this
arrangement might decide to stay away.
Channel 4 is probably finding it
difficult to provide critical independent coverage of the mela. Their
web site uncritically reproduces the figures the mela administration
supplies them with for number of hospitals, police stations etc.,
without further scrutiny. Many of the mela administration’s figures
are suspect; 75,000 latrines? My arse! Even a day’s general survey
will reveal that this is not so. We need to look in greater detail at
the logistics behind this amazing event. Events like these do not come
very often. There is a lot to learn here. We owe it to people who are
interested to give them a better idea of how an event like this can be
put up and sustained. If we follow the facts-and-figures paper trail
supplied by the mela authorities, we will discover, only too late, the
wisdom inherent in the saying "the map is not the territory."
The receipts for what has been purchased and what actually appears on
the ground are two entirely different things. Media! Wake up please.
VIP's
Mauni Amavasya on 24th January
will be a very special day. Kumbhnagar’s population will mushroom to
many millions. Fifteen million, twenty million, thirty million? We will
have to wait and see. There are a number of ghats for bathing in, but
most will prefer to bathe in the ghat at the Sangam. A large chunk of
the Sangam ghat is already reserved for shahi snans of the various
Akaharas. This leaves less space for the rest of the ordinary pilgrims.
What happens should India’s Prime Minister Mr. Atal Behari Vajpayee
decide to turn up for a dip? King Birendra of Nepal is also interested
in coming. The Dalai Lama says he, too, might turn up. This is the
nightmare scenario for the mela’s security team. An act of terrorism
here at the mela might at least make heroes of some of them, but
providing security to VIPs like these and getting them to the Sangam
with millions of pilgrims having to be re-routed – no thanks! A
similar situation created a number of casualties in 1954. Mauni Amavasya
is indeed going to be an interesting day.
Tony
Fernandes is Zenzibar's correspondent at Kumbh Mela 2001 in Allahabad,
India. You can contact him at tony@zenzibar.com
|